Pages

FNF (Round 1): M5 results and The Veiled Avenger vs. "the heroine"

Round 1, Match 5 results


Ion vs. Mad Dog

As I see it, the outcome of this fight would probably come down to an issue of whether Mad Dog could seize the element of surprise. 

Both the combatants have super strength...but Ion is a teenager, whereas Buzz Baxter is a former Air Force colonel.  In terms of raw fighting skill, then, I'd have to assume Mad Dog's superiority.  You might argue that his insanity reduces this advantage, but the legendary battlefield prowess of the Viking berserkers blunts (if it doesn't completely invalidate) that argument.

If Mad Dog gets the jump on Ion, the next critical question would be whether he could pierce the teen's forcefield (especially with his fang venom). It's difficult to determine this. According to Wikipedia, Mad Dog has bionically strengthened jaw muscles to increase his biting strength, so that might make you think the Mad Dog could take him down if he could get into a close-quarter row. On the other hand, though, Ion's forcefield has been demonstrated to be powerful enough that a baseball bat cracks over it without hurting him. Even a point-blank blast from a gatling gun does nothing more than "leave a welt."
Thus, even though Mad Dog theoretically could puncture Ion's forcefield, the fact that there's nothing in the specified text of Solo Avengers #9 that would seem to demonstrate his bite power, whereas MOST Comics #1 does show us a super-robust forcefield for Ion.

Despite being a knock-down drag out, given the issues cited above I'd give the slim advantage to Ion.






The Peerless Power of Comics!: It's Not Easy Being Captain America

The Peerless Power of Comics!: It's Not Easy Being Captain America: There's little argument that Captain America holds the respect and admiration of not only his country's citizens, servicemen/women,...


I'd hoped to put out some new content today, but I couldn't quite get
it done to the degree I'm satisfied with.  Thus, rather than throw
something out there half-baked, I'm going to supply a little free
advertising for The Peerless Power of Comics! blog.



As a long-time Captain America fan, I had a strange love-hate response to
this post.  I guess most of my Captain America exposure came shortly
after the Shooter-period ended.  Perhaps that accounts for why I don't
recall seeing the "dark(er) side" of the Sentinel of Liberty that is
chronicled here.

FNF (Round 1): M4 results and Ion vs. Mad Dog

Round 1, Match 4 results

Detective Chimp vs. Wizard

This one really was a toss-up.  Overall, Wizard seemed to have more powers and gadgets.  Against nothing more than Detective Chimp's super-intelligence and normal chimpanzee strength/agility, Wizard would seem to come out on top.

However, in the specific comic referenced for Wizard (Miss Liberty #1) you don't really see him use any of this.  Thus, you might think Detective Chimp would have enough fighting prowess to beat Wizard.

Unfortunately, Detective Chimp doesn't look like much in his specified comic either (Day of Vengeance #3), unless you count sarcasm as a "super-power".

The specified setting doesn't seem like it would affect the fight too much.  Both of these guys are heroes, so I figure neither would do anything like taking a hostage. I'd expect a similar showing in terms of agility and strength.  The only detail that would seem to tilt the outcome a bit is the specification that this setting features, "Hundreds of food carts, gastropubs and clubs offer a plethora of culinary choices and those who feel hungry for something else can enjoy concerts, musea, musical activities or one of the many other recreational venues."

Based on that, and Detective Chimp's established tendency to alcoholism, I'd expect DC to have knocked back a few already.  Inebriated, I figure Wizard takes him down.




---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Round 1, Match 5

This week's fight returns us to a good-against-evil match-up as Richard Nyquist's Ion faces off against the criminal canines of Marvel's own Mad Dog!

Ion as depicted in MOST # 1 (May 2017)

Background on Ion





Mad Dog as depicted in Solo Avengers #9 (Aug 1988)

Background on Mad Dog


Setting

Cliff-side of a glacier overlooking a frigid river opening out to the sea.  There is a small sparsely-populated Inuit village visible in the distance.

Doc Wackey Goes Berserk!: pt. 2 (Smash Comics #37)

Smash Comics # 37 (November 1942)

Midnight feature (Doc Wackey Goes Berserk!)


Last week, we left the super-powered Doc Wackey outshining all competition at the Interstate Track Meet.  Unfortunately, when Doc tries to retrieve the champion's cup, an azure-suited official pronounces our beloved inventor "nuts" and tells him to "scram!"

This dismissal of the hypersonic elderly is not, however, shared by all meet attendants.  Among the remarkably large throng gathered to take in an afternoon track meet, are two members of the Big City underworld.  One, a weirdly bug-eyed chap whom we later learn is named Skull Duggery, has somehow spotted what everyone else  missed--that Doc did, in fact, win the race!




Sorry, but this is plot hole #3.  If the idea is that the race official--whose primary job is to organize and pull off the races--doesn't know Wackey is the winner because the old coot was moving too fast for the human eye to follow, then how does Skull Duggery spot him?  I guess it works if we posit that Skull's eyes look so weird because he's got some sort of superhuman power of his own...sort of like Mantenna from He-Man and the Masters of the Universe

Mantenna

If we grant that possibility, we should consider whether Skull might have some additional powers--like insane charisma. Why do I say this? Glad you asked. 

Following Doc's unceremonious booting from the cinder path, Skull and his unnamed co-worker approach Wackey with a proposal that he abandon goodness and "get even with stupid humanity" (as it turns out, by robbing banks).  Seemingly as soon as he hears the specifics of Skull's evil plan, Wackey signs up enthusiastically.


Bear in mind, dear reader, that this is the same Doc Wackey who's: 

  • been fighting crime alongside Midnight since Smash Comics #23 (Jun 1941)
  • heroically agreed to exchange his life for Midnight's one month ago, 
  • and single-handedly completed a home-construction pro bono one page ago 
but nevermind any of that!  It's totally believable that this weird dude with big eyes wouldn't have to do anything more than suggest, "Hey wanna be a crook?" and Doc's ready to go full Clyde Barrow.

As fortune (or Providence) would have it, shortly after his reversion to criminality Doc bumps into Midnight and company.  Though they still can't communicate with him due to Doc's buzzing verbalization, our (still unnamed) professor has an idea for getting around that barrier!

He leads the entourage across the street to a music shop where he has Doc speak into a recorder.  The prof takes the resultant vinyl (because...it's the 1940s) and plays it on a "very slowly revolving turntable" to find out what Doc's trying to say.  Unfortunately, just as Midnight learns what his old pal is planning, Doc vanishes again! 


This brings us up to--what is it now--plot hole #5?  In the first place, if Doc was this committed to his new path, why'd he bother to go with Midnight and others in the first place?  Why go through all the rigamarole of recording his voice, when there's so many places that need robbing? This makes it look like Wackey is pretty firmly committed to his instantaneous reversion to evil.  (Keep that in mind as we move through the rest of the story.)

Furthermore, even if we buy that Doc is ready to "chase them Benjamins," why would he do so "for Skull Duggery"?  What's Skull contributing to this venture?  I mean, if we do presume Skull has some kind of powers (maybe mind-control) this might make sense...but it's kind of hard to conclude that since Cole never gives us any explicit reference to such powers.

The next thing the reader knows, the First, Second, and Third National Banks are all robbed by Doc. Midnight concludes that the mystery prof.'s injection has "set Doc berserk" (thereby supplying the story both a title and a rationale), so he concludes the rational solution:  mystery prof must now inject BOTH Midnight AND Gabby so they'll be fast enough to catch Doc and put a stop to his wrongdoing!


Plot hole #6 (or 7...really, who's counting anymore?) Okay, so up to this point, we've established that Doc who started this issue as a "good guy" has suddenly gained powers from a serum and also decided to become a villain again.  In other words, the serum made Doc turn to robbery.  The panel above sure makes it seem like this is the conclusion Midnight's reached.  Yet, if so...if the serum amplifies BOTH physical speed AND moral viciousness, WHY INJECT TWO MORE PEOPLE WITH IT?!  Isn't this likely to just produce three super speed villains?  If it's not a guarantee, isn't this at least a potentiality that would be worth, oh I don't know,a moment or two of discussion?

Meanwhile, Doc--for reasons that are never explained--drops off all his ill-gotten loot with Scull (Yep. You read that right.  The spelling of the character's name varies within the same story. #plothole8) only to have the money bags vanish just as quick as they're set down.


Of course the money is retrieved by Midnight who, then, goes on to return it to each of the banks. Following this, Midnight returns to Skull/Scull's hideout to "straighten out Doc."

Since the upper limits of the speed being imparted by this serum aren't really defined, I can't technically call this one a "plot hole," but I would encourage you to consider just how fast Midnight would have to be to pull this off.  Midnight didn't know where Doc had gone once he left the music shop.  Therefore--at best--Dave and Gabby have to: (1) receive the speed serum, (2) split up and scour the city to locate Doc--presumably prior to his thefts so that he'd know where to return the money to, and precisely how much needs to go to each location, and (3) follow Wackey back to Skull/Scull's hideout where he can retrieve the cash before returning it to the banks.


Back at the villain's hideout, Gabby and Skull/Scull are both trying to woo Doc's sentiments.  Midnight shows up and lends his voice, and the reader gets the impression Doc is about ready to rejoin the forces of light.


It comes as a bit of shock, then, when you turn the page only to see a recapitulation of speed lines and befuddled bank tellers as Wackey ROBS EACH OF THE BANKS A SECOND TIME!!!  The fact that these robberies are of Wackey's own volition is underlined by him announcing he's "old enough to make [his] own decisions" and his "mind's made up."  At this point, Midnight reluctantly adopts his standard practice of using force to subdue evil-doers.





So Midnight seizes the Doc and (one supposes) tries to beat some sense into him. (At least, that's how I'm interpreting the whirlwind.)  Eventually--and quite inexplicably--Doc "comes to his senses."  With a morally evasive, "they misled me" (Really, Doc?  Who mislead you?  Wasn't Skull/Scull pretty up front about what he was suggesting from the very beginning?  And did you just announce...like one page ago...that you were "old enough to make up my own mind"?!) and an implied commitment to return the twice-stolen money, Wackey once again, more or less gets a pass from the usually law-and-order focused Midnight.  What the heck is going on here?! 

Having returned the cash, Wackey races back to Skull/Scull's hideout and beats the other robbers (you remember, the ones who haven't actually committed any crimes in this issue!!) unconscious and leaves them for the cops. Then, rather than stick around to face the music himself for--you know, his own felonies--this newly re-re-restored champion of justice decides he wants to go back to the track meet and get a trophy for the mile run.

Unfortunately for Doc, his serum runs out of juice just before the finish line, so our beloved inventor-turned-felon-turned-crime-fight-turned-felon-turned-crime-fighter-again has nothing to show for his trouble except sore feet.



Oh yeah, and we STILL don't have a name or any follow-up on this mysterious professor who can raise the dead and give super powers to old men.
once he says he'll return t

Pick up here

 

FNF (Round 1): M3 results and Detective Chimp vs. Wizard

Round 1, Match 3 results

Last week's fight turned out to be a pretty simple affair to decide.  Nighthawk's first (text-only) story depicts him possessing at least potentially superhuman strength (e.g., he rolls a "huge boulder" over the entrance to a cave) and endurance (e.g., he performs the boulder trick after having pursued a Nazi airplane on foot!).

Unfortunately, the fight parameters specify that we're looking at Night Hawk (Nope, not a mistake.  The spelling of his name changes from the first story to the second) as he was depicted in All New Short Story Comics #1.  By this time, wealthy playboy Jack Filan has become a lot more human.  While he possessed no powers, Night Hawk was very strong and acrobatic.

Unfortunately for Night Hawk, however, he just doesn't demonstrate enough battle savvy to take down Cutthroat.  Despite the fact that Daniel Leighton (Cutthroat) had no superpowers either, he did carry a range of weaponry other than his fists--chief of which was his adamantium-edged blade.

Furthermore, the principle appearance of Cutthroat we're supposed to be consulting (Captain America #395) depicts him as the lone-survivor of a free-for-all to the death between a skilled ninja (Deathstroke) and a super-powered brawler (Mangler).

Finally, given the fact that this fight breaks out on a playground, I think it's more than safe to assume that if  Cutthroat could just take out Night Hawk on the basis of sheer fighting ability, he'd just seize a kid as hostage and force the hero's submission to save the child's life.

Sorry, Jack, but there's no other plausible outcome than:  Cutthroat Wins!



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Round 1, Match 4

This week's fight brings our first non-human competitor as DC's Detective Chimp takes on the Golden Age Wizard by MLJ.


Detective Chimp as depicted in Day of Vengeance #3 (Aug 2005)

Background on Detective Chimp







    Wizard as depicted in Miss Liberty #1 (1944)

    Background on Wizard


    Setting

    This fight takes place in a riverside city, interwoven into a majestic old-growth forest. The vast majority of buildings have been built with many natural elements to keep in line with the forests.

    The skyline is littered with impressive skyscrapers and there is no place on earth with anything like this. Technology thrives here. New cultures have left their mark.  What historically was a city of few cultures has grown into a large melting pot and it's this that unites the 5 million people to this day.

    It's this multicultural identity that has truly left its mark. Hundreds of food carts, gastropubs and clubs offer a plethora of culinary choices and those who feel hungry for something else can enjoy concerts, musea, musical activities or one of the many other recreational venues.

    Doc Wackey Goes Berserk!: pt. 1 (Smash Comics #37)

    Smash Comics # 37 (November 1942)

    Midnight feature (Doc Wackey Goes Berserk!)



    The timeline for this story mirrors the temporal timeline of its readers.  In other words, this takes place one month after the events of Smash Comics #36.  In that story, Midnight was brought back from the dead by a mysterious professor.  In exchange, Doc Wackey agreed to offer his own life to the mysterious figure in one month's time. 

    As the story begins, Midnight still doesn't know that he was actually dead.  Instead, he remains under the impression that he was "merely" unconscious for a week.  



    This brings us to the first major plot hole of this story. Despite the fact that Midnight's death was "worldwide" news; despite the fact that there was a graveside burial; and despite the fact that Dave has been back among the land of the living for a month, the reader is supposed to believe that somehow Wackey and Gab have kept secret the truth of his death from a guy who's day job is working in the news industry!?

    At any rate, a knock upon the door announces the arrival of said "mysterious professor," come to collect his bond. With a tear in his eye and sniff of his sinuses, Doc walks away from his friends with nary a word about who's at the door or where he's going.

    Shortly after Doc's departure, Dave begins asking questions and Gabby spills the beans like a two year-old eating ice cream in a brand new car.  Dave announces that "not on [his] tintype!" will Doc be sacrificing himself, and he and Gab head out to rescue the third member of their triumvirate.

    Meanwhile, Wackey is getting some sort of serum injected directly into his spinal column [from the looks of things] by the mystery fellow whose name Doc still doesn't know!!!

    The mystery prof tells Doc that he should experience a "hot flush...then a sudden increase in your tempo of living" (sounds like the dude is selling Viagra in the Villages)

    Anyway, within moments Doc has raced out of the exam room--apparently now imbued with superhuman speed!  Our mystery prof proclaims his experiment to have been a "success" but then says he'll now have to capture Doc for "further observation."



    Okay, so here's plot hole #2.  If the guy intended for the serum to give Wackey superspeed (and I can only guess he did, since he pronounces the test "successful") then why didn't he have the old codger strapped down to that exam chair in the first place?!  Would that've been too much trouble?  Would it have been more difficult than tracking down and trying to recapture a superhuman speedster through the city?

    The mystery prof isn't in pursuit five minutes before he bumps into Midnight and Gabby.  Naturally, Midnight offers the obligatory threats about how lost data will be the least of the mystery prof's worries if Doc doesn't come through this healthy.

    Grammar Nazi Moment:  In attempting to explain what he's done to Wackey, the mystery prof has injected Doc with a "self-concocted fluid."  Yes, I get the  guy's meaning, but isn't his grammar here bad?  I'm no English teacher, but the way he's constructed this sentence seems to me like it's saying the fluid concocted itself! (Was anyone editing this writing?)

    Meanwhile, Doc is zipping about town single-handedly constructing houses and dominating foot races. 


    So, there's a couple things on this page that warrant comment.  First, I'm used to comic book characters saying odd things.  Up 'til now Luke Cage's "Sweet Christmas!" was my fav...




    but now I think I'll have to start working, "By the great horned spoon!" into everyday conversation.  Here I thought the Tick had come up with something weirdly unique with his catchphrase...but maybe not after all. 



      

    FNF (Round 1): M2 results and Night Hawk vs. Cutthroat

    Round 1, Match 2 results
    I really like both of these characters.  As such, I honestly tried to give them both a fair shot...but I just can't envision any way that Miss Melee doesn't come out the winner of this fight.

    Jose was a tough dude...no question about it...but he's essentially just a brawler with a lot of heart.  He's Rocky Balboa with nunchakas.  True, several of the sites reference his "martial artist" skill...but that appears to primarily be thinking in terms of boxing.

    While a solid boxer is nothing to sneeze at, this doesn't appear to be anywhere near the level of martial arts mastery we see in Miss Melee.

    I also think we have to consider the difference in outcomes of Gangbuster's battle with Combattor (i.e., he got his spine broken) and Miss Melee's show-down with S.A.B.R. (i.e., she's roughed up, but ultimately victorious).  Admittedly, however, Miss Melee got a critical timely assist from Kid Melee that saved her bacon...so I doubt you could make the case for MM strictly on the comparison of those who battles. 

    The dehydration limiter could've made a difference, but I'm going to engage in a little speculation and guess that the chi-force (or whatever Miss Melee tapped into to overcome S.A.B.R.) can also be applied to sustain her physical endurance for awhile.  That doesn't seem too far afield of standard comic book lore, and since Gangbuster has nothing comparable to appeal to...I'm going to have to say "Congratulations, Miss Melee!  You're going to the second round!"



    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Round 1, Match 3
    Round One's third match pits a hero against a villain for the first time this season.  Specifically, we want to know how Chesler's Golden Age Night Hawk (as depicted in All New Short Story Comics #1) would fare against Marvel's Cutthroat (as depicted in Captain America #395)

    Night Hawk as depicted in All New Short Story Comics #1 (Jan 1943)


    Background on Night Hawk




    Cutthroat as depicted in Captain America #395 (Dec 1991)

     Background on Cutthroat 


    Setting
    This fight breaks out on a crowded children's playground.

    Spring Road Webcomic Review Format & Rubric: Part 1

    One of my goals in writing this blog was to supply reviews of independent superhero webcomics. However, one of the perennial challenges of writing reviews (almost any kind) is ensuring as high a degree of objectivity as possible, so that different works are dealt with on at least a roughly similar basis. My solution was to draw on my experiences in academia by using a grading rubric.
    Once that was decided, I had to ponder, “What qualities or features would my rubric evaluate; and why would I choose those qualities/features rather than some other set?”

    My answer to the first question wound up being eight qualities: sustainability, language, violence, sexuality, political leaning, morality, artwork, and storytelling. My answer to the second question is, essentially, “if I care about these things, then there’s probably other people who care about them too.”

    In future posts, I intend to go more in-depth on what I mean by each of these qualities and how I assess them...but not just yet.  For now, I'll end with a few words about the synopsis.   

    The Synopsis.  


    Each review begins with a section I call The Synopsis. This is not, strictly-speaking, part of the rubric. It’s purpose is to supply a broad overview and background to the characters, creators, overall tone, etc.  Some of my synopses (particularly the one for Femme Noir) went on entirely too long.  This year, my intention is to scale way back and keep the synopsis to something nearer the following examples: 

    The Synopsis for Miss Melee

    Miss Melee is a collaboration between writer Rob Johnson & artist Ariel Guadalupe.  It chronicles the struggles of (at least initially-) retired superheroine Janice (Jan) Jones  who has settled down to work an office job and help husband Mark raise their daughter, Jackie.  The comic updates every Saturday, and explores the "working mom theme" of juggling family, corporate employment, and super-heroing. 


    Synopsis for Liberty Lass

    Liberty Lass is an unapologetic celebration of patriotism, cast in the Comics Code compliant style of Bronze Age.  Creator Steve Vincent's love for Bronze Age comics goes so far that he even has a fictional company--the Cosmic Comic Company--that "produces" the title. Liberty Lass is a character originally generated for the online gaming world, City of Heroes.  Currently, Vincent has produced five full issues of Liberty Lass.  

    FNF (Round 1): M1 results and Gangbuster vs. Miss Melee

    Before announcing the winner of our first match, I'd like to present my opinion on who would win.  I say the nod goes to Camaleao Cinzento.

    The superior power set of Black Crow notwithstanding, it seems relevant to me that Black Crow's powers are fundamentally mystic and arise from "the Earth spirit."  However, the specified setting for this battle is "an exoplanet."

    While I can't prove it, my assumption is that there must be some sort of effective range that Black Crow can be away from the Earth before his powers go away.  If you accept that, we could debate just what that range is, but outside the solar system strikes me as obviously too far.

    If you grant that, then Jesse Black Crow is returned to being a paraplegic facing off against a guy who's superpower is pretty much useless anyway (due to his being colorblind).  Camaleao Cinzeto's main strength is not the ability to change color, but simply his ninja skills.  For these reasons, I think he's easily the winner.

    That being said, I pledged myself to honor the community vote.  The community has voted.  Congratulations, Black Crow!  You're going to the second round.



    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Round 1, Match 2

    The next match pits Jerry Ordway & Marv Wolfman's street-level crusader Gangbuster against Rob Johnson & Ariel Guadalupe's domestic diva of destruction Miss Melee!

    Since Gangbuster has changed a bit over the years, I want to specify that this duel presumes the Jose Delgado Gangbuster as he appeared in Adventures of Superman # 434 (November 1987).


    Gangbuster (as depicted in Adventures of Superman #434 (November 1987)

    Background on Gangbuster






    Miss Melee (as depicted in Miss Melee #5 (October 2017)
    Background on Miss Melee 

    Setting
    This fight takes place in a desert setting near twilight.  Both combatants have suffered dehydration and are beginning to feel the effects of heat exhaustion.