Pages

Round 2, Match 1: Black Crow vs. Miss Melee

Round 2, Match 1

Our second round begins by pitting Marvel's Black Crow (a surprise winner from round 1, thanks to votes from readers) against Rob Johnson & Ariel Guadalupe's  mighty momma, the magnificent Miss Melee!

Black Crow as depicted in Spectacular Spider-Man #192 (Sep 1992)

Background on Black Crow


Miss Melee as depicted in Miss Melee #1

Background on Miss Melee


Setting
This fight takes place on a vacant rugby pitch.

Webcomic Review Format & Rubric (Part 2): Sustainability

In the first post of these series, I shared why I started reviewing webcomics, as well as the eight qualities I consider in each review.  The first post concluded with brief comments on the Synopsis section of each review.

Today we'll look more in depth at the first assessment vector:  Sustainability.  This term signifies the likelihood that a comic will keep going. I believe this to be an especially important quality in the world of webcomics where it’s relatively easy to start up. The plus side to this is that we get a lot of new comics started all the time!  The downside is that the less-invested many people are in starting something, the less-invested they are in keeping it up.  (Commitment isn't exactly our "thing" in 2018.)  The Internet is littered with half-finished comics, and it’s frustrating to invest in a story, only to discover that it’s come to an abrupt halt and will (likely) never be completed.

I calculate this score by considering the history of the comic at the time I review it. Have the creators already established a track record of consistently putting out new content?

There's basically three factors that go in to determining the Sustainability rating.

  • How long has the comic been in production? 
    • Less than a year = 1
    • 1-2 years = 2
    • 2-3 years = 3
    • 3-4 years =4
    • 4+ years = 5
  • Is it currently ongoing?
    • no = 0
    • yes = 5
  • Have the creators posted on a reliable schedule? 
    • no = 0
    • yes = 5

To calculate the Sustainability score, simply add the relevant values for a comic and divide by three.

FNF (Round 1): M13 results

Round 1, Match 13 results

As much as I like Vigilante, this one wasn't even close.  At best, Vig brings some cattle-rustlin', a tough (but human) jaw, and a few lead slugs.  Jon Von Ghoul brings the same basic toughness, amplified by an inability to feel pain, mystic and scientific knowledge, and a track record of going mano-a-mano with a mutated monster.  Inspector Von Ghoul wins without even breaking a sweat!